TREASURE HUNT IN EDENâ3
Gold or No Gold? (Sunday Times, August 31, 1958)
By Ian Fleming
Concluding his account of the search for pirateâs treasure, reputed to be worth $120 million, in the Seychelles, Ian Fleming describes his visit to the hunter and the site where strange clues have been found.
With a couple of days to waste before I finally met Wikins the treasure hunter, on the main island of MahĂ©, I sat down in one of the excellent but primitive beach bungalows of the âhotelâ on Praslin Island and put down on paper what I had been able to piece together of the ten-year history of the treasure hunt. My sources are such documents as are available and the evidence of reliable witnesses. I subsequently checked these with Wilkins himself.
The treasure prospectus of 1955 was issued under the impeccable auspices of Messrs. Hamilton, Harrison and Mathews, Nairobi solicitors, and Messrs. Gill and Johnson, a leading firm of Kenya accountants. The result was an immediate subscription of ÂŁ24,000 by some 400 shareholders. Since then, single shares have been bought for ÂŁ4,000 when the market was goodâthat is when it leaked out that Wilkins had found Pegasus in the tenth hemisphere or whateverâbut today I dare say the market is not so firm. But this, as they say on Wall Street âshould not be construed as an attempt to induce the public to subscribe for sharesâ and I personally have no holding.
The Palace Sentry
Reginald/Herbert Cruise Wilkins was born forty-five years ago near Bideford, in Devon, of good yeoman stock. He decided to join the Army and went into the Coldstream Guards. His only military claim to fame is having been a sentry outside Buckingham Palace. In the middle of 1940 he was discharged from the Coldstream Guards as unfit and somehow found his way to East Africa where he became a white hunter. Later, in 1949, he went to the Seychelles and dabbled with the idea of starting a shark-fishery and meanwhile settled down in a bungalow adjacent to the present treasure site. The whole area was the property of a Miss Berthe Morel, subsequently to become the wife of a famous Seychellois, Mr. Arthur Savy.
Mrs. Arthur Savy died two years ago aged eighty-four, having, for the last ten years of her life, kept her coffin slung from the roof of her sitting-room. She is very important in the treasure story. She owned the famous cryptogram and documents which Wilkins is using today and she herself had hunted the treasure on and off for over forty years. Labour is cheap in the Seychelles and to keep a labour force digging and wall-making all that time would not have been too expensive a business. She also owned the land on which the treasure âis.â Wilkins quite naturally met this elderly lady and was several times asked up to her house for tea. On each occasion, he tells me, as he came into the room, Mrs. Savy appeared to shove some papers hastily under the tea-tray . This would have seemed to my suspicious mind as something like a âcome-on,â but not to Wilkins, and in due course he âcame-onâ and asked what Mrs. Savy was hiding.
Then reluctantly the story of the Levasseur treasure came out and his papers were revealed. Wilkins believes they were originally stolen from Government archives in Mauritius where Levasseur was held prisoner before going to the gallows in France.
I asked if this story had been checked in Mauritius. The answer was no. Wilkins, fired with the story, cabled for his mother to come with the idea that he would invest a hundred or two in a hunt for the treasure. (In all he and his mother spent ÂŁ6,700 between 1949 and 1955 when they went to the public for more funds.)
The Diviner
Wilkins then sat down and âdecipheredâ the cryptogram. Having done this to his satisfaction he was convinced that the treasure lay almost under his feet and he went back to Kenya, his head, as mine would have been, stuffed with dreams. As soon as he landed, and as if the Fates had paid for the insertion, he saw in a local paper an advertisement offering to divine copper, gold and diamond mines. Colonel Hennessy, a member of the British Society of Water Diviners, was a Eurasian, born in Bangalore, and had just ceased being Embarkation Intelligence Officer in Bombay. He listened to Wilkins, sent for his lawyer, Mervyn James Eversfield Morgan, barrister-at-law, of Nairobi and the three of them drew up a partnership deed dated July 18, 1949. Very soon they went off to the Seychelles. Sure enough, Colonel Hennessyâs pendulum swung like mad over the treasure site, whirled clockwise here and twirled anti-clockwise there, and the Big Dig was on.
I have seen a copy of Colonel Hennessyâs official report on his divinations and this is a typical extract: âPlot V.: Cavity plus, Gas plus, Fresh water, Salt water, Diamonds and Sapphires, Emerald, Ruby, Brass, Lead, Gold coins, Silk, Steel plus, Copper plus, semi-precious stones, Whale oil, Pearl, Parchment.â â Forgetting the âgas plus,â a pretty attractive inventory.
The partnership lasted for something over a year and what a year it was! They had found it. They hadnât. Now they were on the threshold, and a nurse must be in constant attendance at the site in case Wilkins had heart failure when he saw the gold. The treasure hunters solemnly went to the Government and asked that a cruiser should stand by and be prepared to repel the gold-crazy populace and transport the treasure away to the vaults of the Bank of England.
Hunters Fall Out
But the emotional pressure on the partnership was too great, and at the end of this time the treasure hunters fell out and Wilkins brought a case for âRescission and Nullity of Deedâ against Hennessy and a certain J.P.G. Harris, a Kenya lawyer who seems somehow to have replaced Morgan as Hennessyâs attorney. It was a complicated case; injunctions and adjournments provided handsome fees for members of the Seychelles Bar until, in April, 1951, Chief Justice Lyon declared the case to have lapsed and it faded out. Hennessy, Morgan and Harris then left the stage and their connection with the treasure hunt seems to have ended.
From 1951 to 1955 Wilkins dug furiously in, under and around the giant rock to which he grandly refers as âthe glacis.â The only event of note was his success in involving Government in the affair. The Government investment was a small one. In exchange for two full shares they provided some ÂŁ750-worth of labour and other services by the Public Works Department, but the agreement, dated July 19, 1954, did allow Wilkins and subsequently less respectable people to say quite truthfully that the British Government had come in as a junior partner. However, the small subsidy of 1954 was only a temporary stop-gap. Pumps became necessary and Wilkins had exhausted every penny of his own and much of his motherâs money. There was nothing for it but to give up some shares in the giant treasure in exchange for a modest amount of ready cash. Wilkins went to Kenya, the prospectus was issued and in due course he was back on the site with the necessary equipment.
Now the hunt was again on in earnest and the impatient shareholders in Kenya, thirsting for news, despatched as their representative a certain Colonel J. Kent whose reports on progress caused the market in the treasure shares to veer wildly over the next two years. This was not Colonel Kentâs fault, but Wilkins became more and more unhappy and fell out with Colonel Kent at the end of 1957.
Deliberate Traps
I have read all the reports to shareholders and to me they make fascinating reading as this or that âclueâ is discovered, is run excitedly to earth and in the end turns out to have been a false trail, or, as Wilkins insists, a deliberate trap set by Levasseur. Alas, there is no space for them here.
East of Longitude 10 and South of Latitude 35 (that is approximately East and South of Switzerland), is I reckon the septic zone, as opposed to the antiseptic, in which Britons are fortunate enough to live. Go farther East or farther South of these lifelines and a scratched midge bite may mean an amputation. Anyway, by the time I had explored the Seychelles and talked treasure with everyone that mattered, a small coral cut on the left shin, which I had foolishly not dabbed with Merthiolate, had become a deep festering wound and I was stuffed with medicaments, unsuspected glands were aching, and I had a mild fever. So I was already slightly airborne when I landed on Mahé and motored along the bumpy coast road towards the treasure site across the wide bay from Fairhaven, the admirable guest house in which I had the most luxurious bedroom in the Indian Ocean.
Most unusually for the Seychelles there was an occasional growl of thunder. Rain began to fall heavily and at four in the afternoon it grew dark. To my right it was low tide and, in the shallows out to the reef, the octopus fishermen were bent over the livid pools. An occasional flash of Satanâs Fire, which is more like a huge magnesium flare than our lightning, lit up the scene from time to time as if some celestial recorder wanted a photograph of my first meeting with Wilkins and, due to the gloom, was having to use flash.
I bumped and clattered round the bay, past the romantic Crusoe cottages of the HĂŽtel des Seychelles and the Beauvallon, where most of the keen fishermen seem to stay, and came to an unusually unkempt fishermenâs village in which all the inhabitants seemed to be suffering from pigmentation troubles. I asked the way of a piebald face and was directed onwards a hundred yards. As I pulled up at the side of the road, a skeletal white hound with elemental eyes dashed at the car with a snarl. I knew that the son of the proprietor of the land was in hospital with lockjaw. Rabies raised its dreadful head in my fevered mind. But the hound, after paying an unwelcome attention to my off front wheel, slunk away.
At the Site
The treasure site, as a treasure site, has much to recommend.it. It is well and solidly landmarked, being exactly at the western horn of the longest stretch of sand on MahĂ©âthe mile long North West, or Beauvallon Bay. More or less directly above this point is the 2,000-foot high Mount Simpson. The site itself, at the point and below the mountain, is a giant 100-foot square elephantâs flank of granite that plunges, almost vertically down to the edge of the road and Into a small tidal bay. Levasseur would have said to himself that this cliff of granite would never be obscured by vegetation and it never has been. Somewhere beneath this 1,000-ton rock, according to Wilkins, lies the great treasure and, for all I know, he is right.
I got out of my car and walked towards a lean-to engine shed at the foot of the âglacisâ (the Wilkins treasure lingo creeps up on one). Around me, for about two acres, the ground between the coconut palms looked as if it had been used for a film of the battle of the Somme. Everywhere there were craters full of greenish water, half shored-up walls, rough bits of masonry, little fortifications erected to try to keep back the sea, and the stumps of broken hoists. It was rather pathetic, as if some huge child had been playing with his spade and bucket. The engine shed, containing a well-kept Lister Diesel and a Holman Compressor, stood on the brink of a large and deep-looking crater full of water that extended round the base of the âglacis.â
Never-Smiled
A dozen coloured workers were tinkering, digging, wrestling with chunks of rock. On the edge of the crater sat a middle-aged man, dressed in a clean white shirt, blue trousers and sandals, gazing moodily at an oil slick on the surface of the pea-soup water. I introduced myself and, after dissipating sundry suspicions, we were off into Treasure Land.
Wilkins is a pleasant man. He engenders sympathy. He has steady, truthful but rather blank blue eyes in a totally unlined round face. His thin fair hair, neatly brushed back, and his modest, well-tended moustache are up to guardsman standards. He has a pleasant voice, and if he never smiled in my company, and certainly never laughed, it is perhaps because nothing he or I said amused him.
Stuff of Dreams
For the next hour it was all Andromedas and the Collarbones of Solomon (a hoary treasure puzzle I have not bothered to explore), The Golden Fleece, Pegasus and, of course, these infernal hemispheres (for which I had the good manners not to suggest there was a very much shorter word). Finally I interrupted. I pointed down into the scummy water. âWell, at least youâve found oil,â I said encouragingly.
Wilkinsâs calm eyes looked down at the rainbow slick. âItâs ambergris ," he said reverently.
Thinking âoh Lord, this is where I came in,â I said sympathetically, âWhat makes you think that?â
âThey buried whale oil with the treasure. Must have been a lump of ambergris mixed up with it.â
âWhy did they bury whale oil with the treasure?â
âTo make poison gas. Weâve had to be jolly careful. They were full of tricks those chaps â always trying to lead us up the garden path into some booby trap. Here, Joe, bring the crowbar.â
A large Negro brought the crowbar and prodded into the murky depths. More oil came to the surface. I said, âHave you had the stuff tested or tried tasting it?â
âNo.â
It was always so when I asked Wilkins if he had made the obvious tests. They had never been made. They might have destroyed the dream. I knelt down and dipped my finger in the stuff and tasted it. It was oil, petrol probably. I said so. I also pointed out that the gusher was about six feet away from the engines. Could someone have thrown a half empty can of oil or petrol into the pool at the end of the last dig?
âNo, old man,â said Wilkins pleasantly. âNow just come and have a look at the Andromeda in the fourth hemisphere.â
We scrambled up and over the road to the sand. The tide was coming in and we had to jump for it once or twice. We walked and skipped from granite lump to granite lump. âNow you see over there, old man,â there was a vague pockmark in the rock, âthat circle with the dot in the middle, that represents the sun. And there,â there was an irregular scab on the granite, âTaurus, the bull. See the horns? Now just look down.â I was standing on a ton of rock, more or less, I admit, cruciform. âThatâs just one of the Andromedas. The best one, with her left leg bent, is in Kenya. Now just come over hereâŠâ
Newspapers and Government departments occasionally get letters of many pages in which this sort of stuff is mixed up with the future of Palestine, or a demand for a higher pension. In my rather feverish state, under the dark livery sky, Wilkinsâ richly studded, evenly spoken chronicle of his discoveries began to work upon me like one of these letters and I became desperate to escape. Fortunately rain stopped play. It came down in heavy straight rods out of the doom-fraught sky. With a babble of thanks and a promise to come again I made a dash for my car, whirled it round and was off back through the looking glass.
Looking back at our first of many meetings, I am sure I am doing Wilkins an injustice, or at the very least abusing his hospitable reception of me, in writing this highly charged stuff. My fever did not abate and the next day I was in hospital having a mega-shot of penicillin and giant snacks of aureomycin, and I have a scar on my shin as big as a doubloon to show for it. So it was not until a week later that, more soberly, I had my further talks with Wilkins and I will try to keep the purple out of my prose in recounting the gist of them.
The Clues
Wilkins is certainly no slouch. When I saw him again he had already pumped out the site (â2,000 gallons a minute, old manâ) and a solid looking four foot high wall was marching out into the shallows. âIâm going to curve it round like this,â explained Wilkins drawing with his finger in the sand. âThatâll keep the sea back while I dig under the road.â
âWhy under the road?â
âJust have a look over here. Weâre in the tenth (I think it was) hemisphere and Iâve found the star and the circle. And dead on the bearing at that.â
I followed him reluctantly and waited with some impatience while a workman dug round the base of a large granite boulder and fetched sea water to clean the exhibit
There indeed were two clearly outlined circles or wheels in the rock and these could not possibly, I think, have been cut into granite by anything but human agency. Now suddenly I began to doubt my own scepticism. Certainly a great number of Wilkinsâs âcluesâ were wishful, but now it seemed to me that at any rate some of the rock markings I had been shown, and perhaps many more I had not bothered to look at, could have been made by man.
âHow are you going to get under the road?â
âHave to get Public Works to agree and then build them a bridge, sixty foot, steel and concrete.â
âThatâs going to cost a lot of money.â
Wilkins shrugged. âIâve cabled for Jabby Trent (the latest liaison man with the shareholders) and heâs coming by the next boat. Perhaps we can make do with a trestle bridge.â
Wilkinsâs Labour
When he is working on the site, Wilkins lives in a neat little two-roomed bungalow some fifty yards from the engine shed. We sat down and Wilkins spread out the documents from a bulging briefcase. These all looked very much like what such documents might look like. The basic cryptogram written in ink is on a piece of cloth (not vellum, as Wilkins thinks) without any margins.
I asked Wilkins if he had submitted the cryptogram to any expert cryptographer. No â because after four monthsâ hard work he had been able to decipher the puzzle himself. He showed me his translation. It was full of compass bearings and Greek mythology. The last line read: âMake diagonal at 82 degrees â here is the gold.â
The translation had been in French. Wilkins had known no French . He had had to teach himself the language. I picked up the photostat of a kind of chessboard with the German words âGut,â âBöseâ and âMittelâ (good, evil, middling) neatly scattered among the squares opposite the signs of the Zodiac written down the right-hand margin. Wilkins said indulgently, âThey suddenly broke into Prussian.â Had he unravelled this one? âNo. That one got me stumped.â There were various cryptic letters in spidery French and some aged correspondence with the BibliothĂ©que Nationale in Paris.
There was no particular coherence about the papers and no history of their origin or details of previous work on the treasure. I asked Wilkins if he had been able to find out anything about Levasseur himself. Had he been a man of education? Was there any reason to suppose he had been acquainted with Greek mythology? According to Wilkins, he had taken four years to bury the treasure. Why had he taken so long and made such an incredible rigmarole out of it when a few true bearings mixed up with some false ones would have served as well?
Wilkins had no satisfactory answers to these questions and there is no reason he should have. He was quite certain the treasure was there. He had believed it for nearly ten years and he still believed it. He intends to go on looking for it until the money (ÂŁ9,000 remains) runs out or until his lease of the property expires in 1961. His untroubled blue eyes gazed calmly into mine. We called it a day.
His Armour
I called on Wilkins twice more to try to sort out the jumble of facts and phantasy that jostled each other round and round in my head. I heard the story of the numerous betrayals and attempts at sabotage he had suffered, his persecution by gris-gris (he had suffered mysterious poisoning; showers of stones had descended on his bungalow), the accusations of jobbery in his shares and, at no time throughout this catalogue of slings and arrows, did his even, good-humoured tone of voice become disturbed. It was as if his faith in the treasure had armoured him against all misfortune, or as if he disregarded every adversary except the great pirate who had set his puzzle and laid his traps 200 years before expressly for a man called Reginald Herbert Cruise Wilkins, ex-sentry at Buckingham Palace.
On each occasion I managed to see more clues. There was the copy of the original treasure âmapâ which, alas, I was not permitted to transcribe. This was a simple affairâa few curved lines, a few straight ones, and some groups of numerals. It looked very haphazard to me but Wilkins explained it with a few airy phrases involving the compass and the heavens. I dare say that if anything among the papers is in fact a guide to a treasure, this map might be the most significant. It looked to me more like the sort of thing a pirate of 1720 might have drawnâno frills and certainly no Andromeda. I was also shown some interesting fragments of glazed earthenware jars or phials. One of them bore on its base the following inscription in what seemed to me appropriately antique black lettering:
Pommade de Sain Bois
de Ls DUBOUAIS
Me LECHAUX Phen
Succr BORDEAUX
Bearing in mind that the Seychelles were French until 1814, these fragments could have been left by a previous inhabitant or even by a previous treasure hunter, but Wilkins found them ten feet under the earth and he is sure they were left by Levasseur or his men. I suggested that submission of the fragments to the Museum de Paris would resolve the problem, but here again â and I repeat, it was always so when a common-sense piece of research seemed desirable â Wilkins was satisfied with his own conclusions and with certain inquiries that had been made for him in London.
And so in due course our conversations came to an end and I thanked Wilkins and wished him luck and drove away down the dusty treasure road under the palm trees and left the dreamer dreaming in his dreamland. The next day I said goodbye to this beautiful, romantic, rather haunted paradise and started the long trudge back across the Indian Ocean and to Bombay and thence, in a flick of time, over the roof of the world to London.
Out of paradise and back in reality, what is one to make of The Great Wilkins Treasure? First of all, I am of the opinion that Wilkins is an honest, though possibly a deluded, man. The best evidence of his honesty is. that, in accordance with the terms of the prospectus, at any time during the past four years, Wilkins could have downed tools and pocketed the remaining cash. He could do so today and be the richer by ÂŁ9,000. No, Wilkins honestly believes in the treasure and he is spending his shareholdersâ money in honest and unremitting efforts to find it.
A Fever
And what to make of these âcluesâ he has found? Some, as I have suggested, may be genuine, but a vast number such as the skeleton of a horse (Pegasus), âisland marblesâ made of clay, fragments of bottles, a sea boot, a dollâs head (the best of the âAndromedasâ) and suchlike are surely the remains of former human habitation on and around the site. As for the âdoorâ which Wilkins found, fragments of wall and cement and other signs of human activity in and around the site, I feel sure that these are the remains of the forty-year search by the landowner, Madame Savy.
But when one has cleared away all the mumbo-jumbo, one is left, I think, with the following conclusion: If Levasseur buried a treasure, and if some of his shipmates didnât come and dig it up after he had been hanged, this would have been an excellent site on which to bury it.
And, of course, there is that circle and that star on the rock and, even as you read this, the pumps will be chugging and the twelve men will be digging and blasting while Wilkins sits in the shade with his back against a rock. And, who knows, perhaps at this very moment, a great shout has gone up and Wilkins has struggled to his feet and is running forward â âGold, Master! Gold! Gold!â
One hundred and twenty million pounds isnât a figure â itâs a fever!
Note: The hunt for Levasseurâs treasure continues to this day. Reginald Herbert Cruise-Wilkins kept up the hunt until his death in 1977. Then his son John picked up the baton and has carried it since, though treasure fever has consumed others too. Perhaps the descendants of John Cruise-Wilkins will be still be hunting long after everyone reading this post has died.
But though the treasure hunt continues, this thread must end. I have now exhausted my stash of Flemingâs articles, so unless some kind multi-millionaire buys me a copy of Talk of the Devil, I have no more Fleming journalism to post, aside from his Atticus columns (which will require careful presentation). So my next project will probably be a re-posting of Flemingâs lesser-known interviews. Unfortunately there arenât many of them, because despite his willingness to promote James Bond, Fleming liked his privacy. If you know of any potential leads, please let me knowâŠ
My thanks to everyone who has commented on (or simply just read and enjoyed) this thread and its predecessor.