So true!
One caveat: The good PDs don’t ‘tell us what to do’. The job title for that is not editor, it’s ‘button-pusher’, though there are indeed many button-pushers out there…
The edit suite pecking order on paper is a different one in reality, definitely not b/w. In reality it’s always a collaboration, the extent of which is at the whim of experience and ego.
Good PDs value the insight, fresh eyes and storytelling nouse of an experienced editor. They collaborate to find the best version of the film.
There are also not-so-good PDs that are aware of their limitations and are grateful for an editor who can take the reigns. This means more work for the editor, but that can be mighty rewarding so long as, internally credit is acknowledged, rather than stolen.
The bad jobs are with the PDs who are piss-poor, but ever so well endowed of ego. They believe they are, or worse still, pretend they are (the corporate-psycho) homo-superior of edit suite.
It’s arguments all the way and when all is complete they take credit for what works, despite having wanted the opposite and pass the buck on what doesn’t. I’d like to say that these parasites are eventually found out, but alas more often than not they reach elevated positions, despite all those they’ve crossed being legion.
A couple of times i’ve called them out, but when the mud slinging begins everyone gets covered in it. Now i tend to get the job over with and never work with the psycho again.
Lets not forget the ‘Carry On…’ trend circa early 70s - mid 80s
Nor I, but i imagine you’re right.
It’s a decent stab at a Hitchcockian thriller, rather than an action movie. It’s canvas is pretty small - it’s plot tight, but not particularly cinematic - more suited to tv. But it just about does what it needs to and is always entertaining.
I think 28 Days Later and Slumdog are far closer to the ‘action’ genre than Trance, particularly the former because it’s narrative is on the move location-wise and involves chases/survival. I’m not saying this is all that’s required of a Bond movie, but if you can’t do this stuff (Forster) then you’ll struggle directing Bond.
I think 28 Days made ‘the chase’ and it’s locations feel very fresh, despite the zombie apocalypse genre being already hackneyed. And in terms of gritty, visceral portrayals of survival Boyle has a very strong resume.