Smile 2 (2024)
Naomi Scott, Rosmarie DeWitt
Dir. Parker Finn
It’s the rare sequel that comes along and completely outdoes the original that preceded. Taking the original premise and expanding it further in the way a good sequel should, Smile 2 manages to be both a logical expansion of the universe set out in the original film while at the same time feeling like something that is completely its own thing that can be enjoyed without having had to see the original to fully understand it.
Whereas Smile followed the descent into madness of a psychiatric therapist, Smile 2 manages to, while being a direct continuation of the first film, go off in a completely different direction by directing its attention on troubled pop star Skye Riley (Naomi Scott). Riley is attempting to make a comeback to touring and public life after a car accident killed her boyfriend (portrayed by Ray Nicholson - Jack’s son) and left her badly injured, both physically and psychologically. Smile 2 is about how she deals with (or, as is more often the case, doesn’t) the pressures of carrying not only her own future career prospects but also the livelihoods of all those people working to help make her tour come to life on her still shaky shoulders, but then having to figure out how to move forward once the Smile demon marks her to become its latest victim.
Even though Smile 2 ends up feeling like something quite different from its predecessor, a lot of that comes down to how writer/director Parker Finn both plays with our expectations from the first film as well as our sense of reality. There are large stretches of Smile 2 that can be difficult to discern whether or not they actually happened within the confines of the film’s narrative or if they only occurred in Skye Riley’s mind. This is not a style of storytelling that I usually enjoy, but it is done really well here. Finn’s use of cinematography, music, jump scares, and subversion of audience expectation makes the tenuous grip on reality that the film’s narrative has actually work to its advantage. It’s not necessary for the audience to know whether or not the events that are unfolding on screen are actually real because, whether or not they are physically happening is completely beside the point.
A large part of what makes now both of the films in this franchise work is how they are metaphors for how we, both on an individual level as well as a societal level, deal with issues surrounding mental health. Smile 2, at its core, is about a mentally damaged young woman trying to pick herself back up from a life shattering event and reclaim her future, all while dealing with her incredibly heightened anxiety and inner demons, all of which are cranked up to 11 thanks to the Smile monster. Much like the first film, Smile 2 also works as a commentary on how we as a society deal with issues of mental health and mental illness, as the people immediately surrounding a person suffering from these issues tend not to see what is going on and try to assure the afflicted that everything is fine (hence, the smiles) not knowing that what they’re actually doing is only making things worse for that person, no matter how much that person tries to reach out and make themselves heard.
This is where Smile 2 is at its strongest. With all things being equal, Skye Riley would be someone who would be the polar opposite of being someone who is isolated, but yet that’s the state she finds herself in for much of the film. She’s surrounded by people, all of whom are there, ostensibly, for her benefit, but it never feels that way. And, with that, it must be said, that the single biggest asset that Smile 2 has working for it is Naomi Scott. Hers is a brilliant performance that should stand alongside the very best the horror genre has to offer. Once the opening sequence of the film is over, she is in practically every single frame for the rest of the way, and she completely owns it. She not only plays Skye Riley, she inhabits the character with an ability that audiences don’t often see, especially not in the horror genre. While the film is off making the audience question whether or not what is happening is actually happening, eventually you find yourself not really caring because you know that it is happening, to some degree, in the mind of Skye Riley, and Naomi Scott so completely and totally sells Skye’s mental anguish and desperation to the audience that you can’t help but take the events that are unfolding on the screen at face value. There is a scene in a hospital room prior to the film reaching its climax where Scott manages to run the gamut of emotions that Skye has been subjected to throughout the film in one minute-plus stretch of film in a completely compelling way. It’s a scene that is completely bonkers on the one hand yet, at the same time, is grounded and quite emotional thanks to her performance.
Making the performance even more impressive is the fact that Naomi Scott also performs the songs on the film’s soundtrack and had a big hand in the development and performance of the film’s choreography. There are a few moments in the film where we see Skye rehearsing for the upcoming tour, thus necessitating actual pop songs, which Scott performs superbly. The studio actually put out an EP of songs for the film, a couple of which, “Blood on White Satin” and “Grieved You”, are actually quite good and are better than a lot of the pop music you hear on the radio today. Scott’s voice is incredible and she makes for an absolutely convincing pop star, which further helps the audience’s immersion into the world of the film.
This is not to say that this is a perfect film. There are points where it feels a bit repetitive of the first film. The ending also poses a unique challenge for the film, as well. Once you know that Smile 2 is about a pop star, you know how it’s going to end. Given just how adept the rest of the film was at either subverting expectations or finding clever ways to play around with those expectations, the ending is exactly what you think it would be. But, with that said, it almost has to be that, or otherwise it would be a massive missed opportunity to set up for an inevitable Smile 3.
As sequels go, and especially those in the horror genre, you’d be hard pressed to come up with something that both builds upon the original while also forging its own path as well as Smile 2 does.