SHUTTER ISLAND (2010) 4K Blu-ray
One of my favorite film categories is “I Was Wrong About That One” The movement from certainty that a film is a bomb to begrudging respect to admiration is wonderful–especially when someone else is undergoing it.
But on occasion it does befall even the most seasoned moviegoer, and yes dear reader, in this post I am speaking of moi. I detested SHUTTER ISLAND when I first watched it. It seemed obvious and shallow as it strived for Meaning and Significance. Having won the Academy Award at long last, Scorsese had come a cropper.
Then I saw the film again, and the obviousness was less obvious–two narratives were happening at once, and Scorsese was arranging his shots so that they worked for both of them at the same time.
Then I saw it again (at the Scorsese retrospective at MOMI), and it was really good.
SHUTTER ISLAND has now risen to the point that it will be the Scorsese film I write about in my book about Buddhism and the cinema.
What? Not KUNDUN? (My husband asked the same question.)
No, not KUNDUN. A wonderful movie that I enjoy, but Scorsese provides us with a very Catholic take on His Holiness–more savior than liberator.
But SHUTTER ISLAND–during the making of which Scorsese read Dante and Milton–works as a parable for both Catholicism and Buddhism. Teddy Daniels is in the long line of Scorsese sacrificial/sacrificed heroes–he suffers a downfall, pays for his sins, and finds redemption (a template on which Scorsese has played many variations).
Yet, just as the mise en scene embraces two narratives in each frame, the narrative supports two parables–one Catholic and one Buddhist. Just as scenes are reality narrative and fantasy narrative at the same time, so the two parables are superimposed upon one another–Daniels searching/staggering though both a fallen world and samsara in search of salvation/enlightenment. Scorsese even provides a happy ending (at least by his standards) for both narratives/parables. Remarkable.