I think it’s partly this and also the very real probability that the amount of time they had Bill Murray for was probably very limited. Now, granted, I have no way of knowing that for a fact, but knowing how much Murray has resisted returning for GB3 over the years, it’s not in any way a stretch to assume that he carved out a minimal amount of time to appear in Afterlife. I think if the studio had the confidence in the films to be able to stand on their own without Murray, that we might have gotten more air time for Aykroyd and Hudson, but at the end of the day, I’m happy with what we got.
Even still, the ending is rushed and underdeveloped. I do like that it requires you to know some of the lore from the first film to understand the threat that is growing within the town, but at the same time, some more actual building to the finale would have been good for the film. To get this out of the way, I absolutely adore the movie, but I’ll admit that my bar was fairly low. I wanted to see the original gang in some capacity. I got that and then a nice little film with some really good actors that cleverly built upon the foundation of the GB universe.
Summary
Bringing back Gozer was OK, but I think that perhaps they should have had her appear as a harbinger of something bigger on the horizon. Maybe a showdown with Gozer, the Keymaster, and the Gatekeeper in the middle of the film that is what initially brings the original gang back together, at which point they help the new kids face down a bigger threat that Gozer has been sent to usher in.
Given, though, how long it took this film to finally make it to the screen, with all of the starts and stops, and shredded screenplays, over the years, I was pleased with the result. Again, my bar was rather low, but just the thrill of seeing Venkman, Stantz, and Zeddemore back together again, especially with the slight tease at the end that leaves things open for a return to New York with Ernie Hudson potentially primed to take a bigger role, was all that I really required of the film, and it satisfied that for me. Greedily, I would say that I’m ready for some more films. This one certainly did well enough financially to warrant the return of the franchise for a fourth film while also proving that Bill Murray isn’t entirely necessary for the studio to be able to rake in the cash, but even if this is it for the franchise, I like that it went out in a very touching manner that