I find that odd, given Sherlock Holmes in particular has this idea of what they looked* like from the start that’s not disputed, yet they constantly are changing. Superman never does.
I’m not arguing, I’m just wanting to enjoy the conversation.
As noted upthread, Superman’s “look” is his face, whereas other heroes’ look is their masks. People raised a stink about Keaton initially but in the end the Batman costume was very well done and when he put on the cowl, he was Batman. Ezra Miller looks nothing like the Flash but in the outfit…well, kinda. The various Spider-Men look nothing like each other or the comic, but with a mask covering their entire face (and/or turned into a CGI mannequin), it’s irrelevant. Aquaman I can’t explain, except that the comic version never gets any respect anyway so maybe the only way to go is a complete do-over.
Superman without dark hair, a solid jawline, decent height and a respectable (but not massive) build would be like Batman without the ears, or Wonder Woman in a track suit (sorry, Cathy Lee). In fact, I’d even have issues if he didn’t have blue eyes, and as much as I enjoy Tyler Hoechlin’s take on Superman, it bothers me that he sports a trendy stubble on his super-chin.
Tyler Hoechlin without stubble tends to look like…
Which is a hard push of a supposed dad of teenagers, no matter how much “well, he’s got kryptonian dna” lines they push
Agreed. Wonder if DC and MCU have overextended themselves with all the upcoming phase 5 stuff and DCEU reboot. Bet there are a lot of folks out there that are glad the checks have already cleared.