I’m trying to remember some of the more interesting audience reactions from past viewings.
I remember seeing “The Wrath of Khan” and when the USS Reliant soared overhead, filling the screen, some wag down front yelled “De Plane! De Plane!” I normally don’t care for the class clown types, but that was admittedly pretty funny, given we were all waiting for Montalban to appear.
Cap wielding Mjolnir in “Endgame” got a big cheer, obviously, and Indy shooting the guy with the swords in “Raiders” had folks howling.
I may have had the most fun with a viewing of OHMSS about 5 years ago. Draco’s “spare the rod, spoil the child” got laughter with an “OMG, the things they used to get away with” vibe, then at the end when Tracy was shot, some lady down front gasped, “Oh NO!” which got a big laugh, because who would have shown up for that movie not knowing what would happen? As far as that goes, who could grow up on episodic TV and not know the hero’s new bride always gets killed at the end? Anyway, that one was a special case because I already knew the film backwards and forwards, so using part of my brain to monitor audience reactions made it more interesting, not less. It was unexpected fun to realize so many people in the audience were utterly unfamiliar with such an old film.
When my wife and I watched the Guy Pierce version of Count of Monte Cristo, a family sat behind us who checked off every negative trope in the book: one of them read subtitles out loud, another constantly asked questions like “which guy is this again?” and another yelled warnings and instructions to the characters. At first it was annoying, but then it got to be funny, like we were on Candid Camera or participating in some piece of performance art.
Another memorable experience was “Star Trek 5: the Final Frontier.” At the start, the room full of Trekkies laughed at every joke, no matter how lame, out of love for the characters and conditioning from the previous, comedy-oriented entry, but when the film ended and the lights came up, there was no applause, no conversation even, just a funereal silence as we all filed sullenly out of the theater looking down at our feet, as if in some unspoken pact never to reveal to anyone that we’d all been at the scene of the crime.